Did You See? with Jena and Michelle
Did you see that? Whether it’s in the news or pop culture, in print or online, we are living in a media overload. It’s a lot to process!
Did You See? is for anyone looking for space to pause and work through the media moments shaping how we see and understand the world. Michelle Ciulla Lipkin spent 25+ years in media and education — as a media literacy educator, advocate, and CUNY lecturer. Jena Wuu spent 15+ years in tech and policy — building Uber in Europe and founding Meta's global information ecosystem program.
Two friends, two different perspectives on the same media landscape, and a shared belief that there’s always something more to the story.
Did You See? with Jena and Michelle
Did you see that Jonathan Haidt said Meta was planning a whisper campaign against him?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Did Meta plan a secret campaign to discredit The Anxious Generation author, Jonathan Haidt? Why are his critics now having to defend their credibility?
UC Irvine professor Candice Odgers is one of many researchers challenging Haidt’s claims. Her work points to other factors affecting teen mental health and argues that social media bans punish rather than help young people.
Jena and Michelle also discuss whether organizations can work with tech companies without losing their independence. Jena shares the corporate perspective, while Michelle offers the nonprofit side.
Plus: The midterms deliver historic firsts and voters push back against Big Tech.
READ JENA'S ESSAY
Even a blue wave can’t save bad tech policy, 2026.
OUR RECS
Conversation with Candice Odgers & Jon Haidt: “Making sense of the research on social media and youth mental health,” University of Virginia, Thriving Youth in a Digital Environment (TYDE), 2024.
We’re not the anxious generation by Maximilian Milovidov, 2025.
AUDIO CLIP
What we’re getting wrong about teens and tech, Candice Odgers, TED, 2026.
2026 MIDTERMS
The 2026 midterm elections showed DEI is alive and well, Brookings, 2026.
The backlash against AI, in four charts, Fast Company, 2026.
Erratic, Distracted, Extravagant: How Elon Musk’s huge midterm bet flopped, The New York Times, 2026.
Voters rejected data centers. Many will be built anyway., The New York Times, 2026.
The youth shifts that defined the 2026 midterm elections, CIRCLE, 2026.
JONATHAN HAIDT
Jonathan Haidt (Instagram), 2026.
Meta considered a “whisper strategy” to turn academics against Jonathan Haidt, The Verge, 2026.
Sanders’ letter to governors, Arkansas legislature concerning the mental health crisis kids are facing driven by social media, Governor SHS, 2024.
TIME100 Health: Jonathan Haidt, TIME, 2024.
RESEARCH ON YOUTH MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIAL MEDIA
Assessment of the impact of social media on the health and wellbeing of adolescents and children, National Academies, 2024.
Do smartphones really cause mental illness among adolescents? Ten problems with Jonathan Haidt’s book, Parenting for a Digital Future, London School of Economics, 2024.
The great rewiring: Is social media really behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness? by Candice Odgers, Nature, 2024.
No. I was not paid to critique The Anxious Generation. I came to the conclusion that the science was flawed all on my own., Growing Up Digital (Candice Odgers), 2026.
No one paid me to disagree with Jonathan Haidt. It was teenagers who taught me that he was wrong., Made Not Found (by Danah Boyd), 2026.
We interrupt our usual programming to inform you that I was never hired by Facebook to do a hit job on Jonathan Haidt., Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science (Andrew Gelman), 2026.
Somehow there's this narrative that if you're not supporting a ban, then what you want is for kids to spend 10 hours a day online getting sex torted on Instagram and Snapchat. And it's like, why can we not have a middle ground there? Why can multiple things not be true?
SPEAKER_01It is unbelievable for someone to have the ability to literally name a generation of people as anxious and not have to back that up with data and with science. I'm Michelle. I've spent over 25 years in media and education.
SPEAKER_00I'm Gina. I've spent over 15 years in tech and policy.
SPEAKER_01We met because we were both working to make social media a better place to be from different angles.
SPEAKER_00I had just started Meta's Global Information Ecosystem Program.
SPEAKER_01And I was the executive director of the National Association for Media Literacy Education.
SPEAKER_00We became friends because we're both obsessed with media. News, books, films, TV, and yes, digital content.
SPEAKER_01We talked for hours about it, not always agreeing, but always learning from each other.
SPEAKER_00There is so much media these days. And we wanted to create a space to process it and work through what it all means for our culture, our politics, and how we understand the world. And
SPEAKER_01we're hoping you do too. This is Did You See with Gina and Michelle. Hi Gina.
SPEAKER_00Hi, Michelle. How are you?
SPEAKER_01I'm good. Although it's getting cold already.
SPEAKER_00Yes, winter came very quickly here too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's crazy. So yesterday I was scrolling and I saw this political cartoon of Winnie the Pooh, and he was like in a honey pot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, I totally don't understand what's going on there. And I just scrolled past it. And then last night I saw your post and referred to something called honey potting.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And then I was like, what am I missing? You need to explain to me and the people what is honey potting.
SPEAKER_00Okay, can I ask a question? Was Winnie wearing a leather jacket?
SPEAKER_01He was. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So it's about Nvidia.
SPEAKER_00It's about Nvidia and Jensen Huang. And I actually first came across the term honey potting recently as well in an episode of Slow Horses on Apple, which I love.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And there
SPEAKER_00is a character who is a very nerdy guy, very bad with women, kind of obnoxious.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00And there's an episode where he gets his new girlfriend who's this beautiful woman, very intelligent. Everyone's like, what is going on? There has to be something wrong. And it turns out that she is a spy from another country and she honeypotted him.
SPEAKER_01So that's what happened with Jensen Huang.
SPEAKER_00Yes. He's been honeypotted.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh, I had no idea and that's just been a phrase out there in the universe that I've never heard before.
SPEAKER_00I guess so. I think it implies why else would somebody who is so attractive be interested in this person?
SPEAKER_01Got it.
SPEAKER_00It has to be because they had some kind of nefarious intention.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Okay. Thank you for that lesson. Now I will understand, and I'm gonna go back and look at that cartoon again and see if it makes me laugh. Let's get down to business. So, uh, Gina, did you see the absolute blue tsunami ass whooping, complete rebuke of the current administration that happened on November 3rd?
SPEAKER_00I sure did. Mississippi.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh, yes. What a history lesson. There is a lot to say about the midterm. I'm gonna share my personal three takeaways. So the amount of historic firsts in this election is hard to ignore. This midterm gave us the first Muslim senator, the first Latina governor in Texas, the first black woman governor in Georgia, Ohio's first woman governor,
SPEAKER_00the
SPEAKER_01first openly gay male senator in New Hampshire, the first Native American woman governor, Florida's first black governor, Minnesota's first woman governor, and then Scott Cologne became Mississippi's first black senator since the 19th century. So any way you look at this, whether you agree, disagree, sad, happy, this is historic.
SPEAKER_00I did not know about a lot of those election results. That's incredible.
SPEAKER_01Number two is that young people are speaking and they seem to have a really clear voice. So according to Circle at Tufts University, the House vote for young people age 18 to 29 went 66% to Democrats.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_01And in New York State, which is the one I looked at with my students, 71% of 18 to 29 year olds voted Democrat. And that was a 26-point shift from 2024. And so far, the data that's coming in all over the country is that 18 to 29 year olds leaned heavily Democrat. And I think this is a story we need to pay attention to because it does really seem like young people have a clear stance on where they want to see politics
SPEAKER_00going.
SPEAKER_01And it was powerful in this midterm.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's going to be really interesting to see how future elections and politics continue to evolve as more and more digitally native people come into voting age.
SPEAKER_01That's what I'm most excited about. I can't wait to see the really like niche data on like 18-year-olds and 19-year-olds because two years ago, the 16-year-olds couldn't vote and they voted this year. What is that shift of that really like younger set is going to be really interesting to notice.
SPEAKER_00Yes. My
SPEAKER_01third and final takeaway of this midterm election is that the most money did not win.
SPEAKER_00Yes. So
SPEAKER_01the five top donors were Republican and spent over a billion dollars on Republican races that went Democrat. Now, I want to be clear that hundreds of millions of dollars were spent on Democratic races, and the issue of money in politics is one that we haven't even come close to addressing. But what this particular data point about all of the money that went into losing races says to me is that our democratic systems held.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01That in the end, what mattered most was the fact that people came out and cast their votes. And this was clearly power of the people over power of the money. And that feels like a really huge part of this election.
SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely. And on the topic of money, did you see that pushing back on tech was a big motivator for voters this year?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, it's hard to even look at this election without thinking about Elon Musk and AI and all of the things.
SPEAKER_00And the half a billion dollars that he quote frittered away on trying to buy
SPEAKER_01votes.
SPEAKER_00There is generally a frustration with power inequity and the power that is consolidated with billionaires. And a lot of that is symbolized in the tech industry. And a lot of that is AI related, of course. I read a report that AI is less popular among American voters than ICE. And we saw that really play out in this election season. The New York Times reported that in 40 out of 41 ballot initiatives around the country, citizens voted to limit or prevent data center development.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of that made me think about how tech companies manage their reputations. And this is personal to me in my career because I used to work in public policy at
SPEAKER_01Uber
SPEAKER_00and Meta, which we'll speak a little bit more about later. I wrote about this experience last week in my newsletter, Feed for Thought. Meta has a very politically reactive approach to how it manages its reputation and its government relations. And I think you can see that evolution. There was a time where Obama was the first presidential candidate to really use social media to reach voters.
SPEAKER_01And there
SPEAKER_00was a lot of celebration about that, reaching people who were typically ignored during campaigns. And then there was a very strong conservative backlash about Facebook being biased against conservatives. And then, of course, in 2016, Trump was elected, and there was a lot of scrutiny about political bias in the other way. In my own experience, I built a program to improve the quality of information, to work with organizations on media literacy education to help people understand the content that they are seeing and what they want to trust. And I had literally been told during routine planning in 2023 that continued support for my program would depend on who was in the White House next year. And we all know what happened. My program lost its funding and I left the company in 2024. And this is the approach that a lot of companies taken, not every company, but many do. And I think that the tech companies, seeing the pushback on AI, seeing the electoral results that are coming in, really need to think about who are we actually trying to serve? Is it about our users or is it about politics?
SPEAKER_01I love everything you write. Just gonna put it out there.
SPEAKER_00Thank you.
SPEAKER_01This particular piece, it was just really insightful. And I felt like, oh my God, I'm learning as I'm reading every line. And I don't usually do this, Gina, but I want to quote you to you. I love this. You say it is never in a company's interest to decide their products or policies in any political figure's image. Because once the political tides change, and they always do, they're left scrambling to ask for forgiveness and reinvent their principles. For a company as consequential as Meta, this lack of foresight is inexcusable. That's so good, Gina. Oh,
SPEAKER_00thank you.
SPEAKER_01So clear.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. I've never been quoted to myself.
SPEAKER_01This idea that you were in a position where you were ready to move forward with a program and you had to wait to see who ended up in the White House is a really, really good example of the dynamics we're talking about.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't feel great.
SPEAKER_00No, but seeing the strong rebuke to the Trump administration, who I think felt so insurmountable for a long time. I hope that this can be a lesson to companies that we really can't rely on these politics. We really need to build products and services that are principles first, because that's what's actually going to be durable.
SPEAKER_01I love that. Okay, well, let's let's get to the meat of it, shall we?
SPEAKER_00Let's get to it. Michelle, did you see that Jonathan Haidt said that Meta was planning a whisper campaign against him?
SPEAKER_01I did notice his name coming back into the news, Gina. Please tell me more.
SPEAKER_00So I'm gonna give some quick background for anyone who may not know who Jonathan Haidt is. He is a social psychologist at NYU Stern School of Business. He is probably best known for a book he published in 2024 called The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness.
SPEAKER_01And we talked about this a little bit already, right?
SPEAKER_00We did on our first episode ever. We spoke a bit about Jonathan Haidt's book. And the premise is essentially that the rise of smartphones and social media haven't just changed how children grow up now, but that it actually harms them and drives anxiety, depression, and self-harm among young people.
SPEAKER_01And as
SPEAKER_00we mentioned in that first episode, Haidt says that we can solve the youth mental health crisis within two years if we implement four simple solutions. And they are
SPEAKER_01no-tell everyone.
SPEAKER_00Here's the secret, everyone. No smartphones before high school, no social media before 16, phone-free schools, and more real-world independence and free play. Now, the influence of this book around the world is really hard to fathom and really hard to describe. Jonathan Haidt has become a very prolific public policy advocate and kind of the face for a movement around the world on social media bans for teens under 16. And he's been very successful at it. A ban went into law in Australia in 2025. The UK will be implementing a similar social media ban next year. And in the United States, there are a lot of conversations on the federal and state levels about restricting kids' access to social media. The governor of Arkansas, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, actually sent a copy of The Anxious Generation to the governor of every U.S. state and territory as part of advocating for greater social media restrictions for young people. Yeah. That's just one example of how influential this singular book has been.
SPEAKER_01Wow, that is quite a fun fact. Did not know that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So naturally, social media companies are aware of who Height is and his influence on public policy and the narrative that he has been pushing about social media harming kids. So Meta was in court recently in California about social media addiction. I don't know if you saw that, Michelle. It's a little confusing because they're always in court for something or another. So, but there were some court filings in California and there were some internal notes from Meta that were part of disclosures. And one of them were minutes from a meeting of people discussing Jonathan Haidt and ways to push back against his narrative in the public. One of the people mentioned in the notes is Curtis Cobb, who is a vice president of research. Full disclosure, I worked with Curtis and his team during my time at Meta. So I do know him, but I don't know anything about this meeting. I only know what everybody else knows from these documents. The people at Meta were talking about, quote, how do we get the academic community to disavow height? Can't co-opt them. So how do we enrage them? So the media finds him not credible.
SPEAKER_01So that's the whisper campaign?
SPEAKER_00That's the whisper campaign. And that, from what I can tell, is the only thing publicly available that refers to the so-called whisper campaign. It's not clear if anything came of this or if anyone at Meta actually did anything. But Jonathan Haidt had found out about this and he posted about it, ironically, on Instagram, which is owned by Meta.
SPEAKER_01That's fantastic.
SPEAKER_00So at this point, I think it would be helpful, Michelle, to go through who some of these people are in the academic community because Jonathan Haidt gets a lot of attention himself, but there's a whole ecosystem of academics who work on these issues.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for all that background and reminder of who he is. And I do recommend going back and listening to our first podcast where we laid some of this out even in more detail. I'd love to start with Candace Odgers, if that's okay. She comes up in the conversation around the whisper campaign, but I realized that we had mentioned that she was coming out with a TED talk and we never talked about it. So I kind of want to start there. Full disclosure, Gina and I kind of fangirl around Candace Odgers because she's been a really, really powerful voice in this conversation. And this TED talk that she released in April is titled What We're Getting Wrong About Teens in Tech. Just to give you a little bit of background about Candace, she's a Chancellor's Professor of Psychology and Informatics at the University of California, Irvine. She co-directs both the Child and Brain Development Program at the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research and CIRIS, an international network evaluating the impact of digital technologies for children and adolescents. And she has been working for over 20 years in the space of adolescent mental health. And she and her team actually follow thousands of 10 to 14-year-olds with consent, of course. They collect daily phone-based reports on mood, time, use, and companionship. They also look at school records, sleep, step counts, online activity. Just putting it in context, she has a lot of experience in this space. She is probably the loudest voice in this debate and has the best known critique. She published in Nature after the Anxious Generation was released. And her critique says that hundreds of researchers, myself included, have searched for the kind of large effects suggested by height. Our efforts have produced a mix of no small and mixed associations. Most data are correlative. This is not just our data or my opinion. Several meta-analyses and systematic reviews converge on the same message. An analysis done in 72 countries shows no consistent or measurable associations between well-being and the rollout of social media globally. Height, a social psychologist at New York University, is a gifted storyteller, but his tale is currently one searching for evidence. So she came out strong, and her TED talk, which we highly recommend everyone listen to, is really worth 12 minutes of your time because she lays out her case. Because remember, Jonathan Haidt has a really big audience, a big platform. And some of these researchers don't, right? So in the TED talk, she talks about how the trends are real, right? Sadness and anxiety for US teens is up, as well as suicide risks. She shares some better trends that are happening, like the fact that teen violence and alcohol use and pregnancy are at record lows. She also brings up that high school graduation rates are actually at historic highs. She shares that her research and other longitudinal studies say that social media just doesn't show up as a predictor of teen mental health. And she points to other factors that are causing this increase in anxiety and depression, right? She talks about caregivers' mental health as the strongest predictor of children's mental health and life outcomes. And that that cause is much deeper than smartphones or social media. She's really looking at the adults around children and what we are doing to support them. She cites staggering data about the scale of family loss that from 1999 to 2020, 1.2 million children lost a parent to drugs or firearms. She does not support the bans because she feels that they punish young people and that there's no evidence that it will actually solve the problem we're trying to solve. I trust her perspective. I think that is really what the evidence says. I like how she pushes back on the narrative about teenagers today and why that narrative gets so much attention.
SPEAKER_02One of the most consistent things we have found is that the stories that you and I are told repeatedly every day about teenagers today, that they are lost, that they are worse off than ever, that somehow smartphones and social media have destroyed them and their brains, it doesn't match the data. And it doesn't match what they tell us. There is a massive gap. And as I've tried to make sense of this gap, I keep coming back to a simple truth that we all know. Scary stories sell. They always have. And the more often you hear something, the more likely you are to believe that it's true.
SPEAKER_01To me, the most salient point she makes is the connection between adult caregivers and youth mental health and to really think about where our resources go.
SPEAKER_02We need to invest in the adults around children. Did you know that the ratio of counselors to students in U.S. middle schools is one to five hundred? Spending millions of dollars on yonder poaches to lock up kids' phones is not going to solve that. We need to take that money. We need to hire teachers, we need to hire counselors, and we need to pay them well.
SPEAKER_01There are so many people that say she's not being hard enough on big tech. And I totally disagree with that because she is really clear about how she feels about what we need.
SPEAKER_02Big tech does not get a pass. This cannot fall to parents and teachers. We require more regulation, but bands don't do that. They let companies off the hook. Instead, we need to fund teachers. We need to build communities and spaces for children and teenagers to play and to learn. And we need to deliver effective digital mental health services and digital literacy programs to young people where and when they need them.
SPEAKER_00It makes so much sense that caregivers' mental health plays such a huge factor in the kids that they are caring for. But I feel like it's a much easier solution to focus on something like a ban than it is to think about all of these other bigger issues about supporting teachers, about supporting caregivers. About counselors and digital literacy education, like those are really hard things for us to grapple with. Hard
SPEAKER_01and expensive, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01As Gina said before, Candace is not the only researcher that has come out and said that Height's story is not based in solid science. So we have a list of researchers: Amy Orban at Cambridge, Andrew Zabelski at Oxford, the London School of Economics, Christopher Ferguson at Stetson University, Jeff Hancock at Stanford's Social Media Lab, or some others who have come out to say that just the science doesn't add up to Heights claims. And I want to be clear, they're not saying that there isn't a crisis that needs to be solved. What they're saying is it's not a direct causation, right? They're saying it's more complicated. Significantly, in 2024, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine issued a report called The Assessment of the Impact of Social Media on the Health and Well-Being of Adolescents and Children. This is the same year that the book came out, and it says in it clearly that the scientific literature on the health effects of social media use is mixed and inconclusive. In 2023, the Surgeon General's advisory on social media and youth mental health said clearly that more research is needed to fully understand the impact of social media. The American Psychological Association's health advisory on social media in 2023 says using social media is not inherently beneficial or harmful to young people. So there's all of this evidence building that we don't really know all of the information that we need to know to make incredibly powerful, impactful decisions like social media bands. Like we don't have that information, but we do have a lot of information about other mental health risks and interventions that work. If you reround to where we started on this whisper campaign, now at this moment in time, we're seeing these researchers have to come out and say, no, I didn't get paid for this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So basically, what has happened since that kind of reporting came out about those meeting minutes is that now there's all this suspicion about researchers speaking out against the science in Heights book. And on October 28th, 2026, Candace Auders published a subsect that said, no, I was not paid to critique the anxious generation. I came to the conclusion that the science featured in it was flawed all on my own. And then her subtitle was, I can't believe I have to write this post. Dana Boyd, another researcher, had to write a post saying, no, I was not paid to critique the anxious generation. I came to the conclusion that the science featured in it was flawed all on my own. Andrew Gelman from Columbia University, who seems to be the one that is named in the meeting minutes, says he was never approached by Meta.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01So what is happening here? That now people who are literally doing research, that's their job. They are researchers, are now being accused of being in the pocket of big tech.
SPEAKER_00It's scary.
SPEAKER_01It is wild what is happening right now.
SPEAKER_00Can we talk about you cited so many academics and so many studies and points of data? Why is it that this one narrative gets so much attention over the rest of the field?
SPEAKER_01That's the question, right? And it seems to me the argument of a good story being more compelling, more interesting than intense, heavy academic research. It is a much easier problem to solve if all we have to do is take away social media and phones, and all of these issues with teen mental health will go away. These other societal issues that would need to change would take so much money, time, effort that there's a narrative about let's just get big tech that's just more appealing. It's more appealing to Jonathan Haidt's PR people, it's more appealing to government, and it just tells a better story. And I think what's really important to stress again is that no one is saying that we don't have a problem. But I also take issue with the way that Haidt frames this generation of people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It is unbelievable for someone to have the ability to literally name a generation of people as anxious and not have to back that up with data and with science.
SPEAKER_00That is very interesting. So I've been thinking a lot about this. And as you know, Michelle, I have a goal. I would like to write a book one day.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00And I've been spending a lot of time this year trying to learn how to do that. And so I've been speaking with book agents, I've been speaking with some of my friends from the news space and um with PR people. Like, how do you become somebody that people would like to give a book deal to?
SPEAKER_01I love that question.
SPEAKER_00And the advice has been pretty consistent across the board is that you need to find a new angle or talk about your issue in a way that feels fresh. So it doesn't sound
SPEAKER_01like
SPEAKER_00the same thing that everybody's been saying for a long time. And it needs to be something snappy. Examples that have been given to me are things like lean in from Cheryl Sandberg or Let Them from Mel Robbins. You know, it needs to be kind of branded and feel new, right? Even though you're talking about a similar thing. And so I think that the anxious generation is another example of that. It's very catchy, it's instantly recognizable, and it speaks to the audience's own fears and emotions. The challenging part of that, obviously, is that one, it is effective, and so it tends to drown out the other things because there are many factors contributing to the youth mental health crisis, and we need better education and support for everybody. That's just not as punchy.
SPEAKER_01Yes, true. True. Yeah. It's not a good sound bite.
SPEAKER_00But then we also end up in this world where you're either for or against. And that's where I think Hayek has been very effective. He talks a lot about sexual exploitation or sex torsion, in his words. And he really gets at emotional topics that are very hard for you to push back against. Of course, nobody wants that stuff on the platforms. Of course, the platforms have to do more to protect everybody, not just young people, from sexual harassment online.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But somehow there's this narrative that if you're not supporting a ban, then what you want is for kids to spend 10 hours a day online getting sex torted on Instagram and Snapchat. And it's like, why can we not have a middle ground there? Why can multiple things not be true? Oh
SPEAKER_01my gosh, yeah. My blood is starting to boil a little bit. You just hit on the thing that frustrates me the most. It's not like these researchers are saying sexual exploitation online is okay. It's not like they're saying that eight-year-olds getting access to pornography is okay. Like, come on. We know those things are not okay. We don't want to see those things happen. We want kids to be safe. And what he does really good height is that even when you see him do interviews, when you see him do his TED talks, he always brings up these individual examples. Like, I spoke to an 11-year-old the other day, and he was saying that blah, blah, blah. And it's like all of a sudden, that speaks for all 11-year-olds.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think he is a brilliant storyteller. And then what we have to look at is the responsibility of everyone around them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Saying that that story is enough to make us change policy.
SPEAKER_00He relies also on a lot of internal reporting from the companies. Yes. We also need to recognize that these platforms are publishing reports on safety incidents. So everything in there is going to look bad. No company does transparency reports about positive or neutral interactions happening on their platforms. And the goal of publishing these transparency reports are for transparency and also to try to say, okay, these are some of the issues that are happening here. How can we work with safety advocates, with law enforcement, et cetera, on addressing these challenges? But it's somehow being weaponized as a proof point that they are really dangerous places.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that he really dives into that in his latest TED talk. He does use internal research a lot in his talking points, in his interviews, in his panel discussions, which I catch all the time. But if you weren't aware of the things that you just presented, that comes across as really damning.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But it's really without context.
SPEAKER_00Right. I used to work on trust and safety policy at Uber. When I was there, there would be an incident on less than 1% of rights. Which statistically sounds like a pretty good track record, but of course, any incident is too many. Right. And so it's a hard argument for the companies to make because obviously there's never enough that you can do for safety. And when you look at the grand scheme of things, the rate of safety incidents is pretty low for the users. Again, the platforms absolutely need to do more. But when people focus on just these reports, it can be a very skewed view.
SPEAKER_01I do want to talk about the way tech partnerships work because, you know, that's how we met. And when you were at Meta, you supported our media literacy efforts around the globe in really powerful ways, like made a real impact for the National Association for Media Literacy Education, but also led to incredible work being done in Australia. We saw major impact from the support that you gave in your position at Meta. And of course, we had a lot of pushback about taking money from Meta, which we've talked about a lot. I don't know. I would love to get thoughts about how do tech companies work with nonprofits and researchers and why is this more complicated than don't take money from Meta.
SPEAKER_00In this case, what Height's really trying to say is that if you are a researcher working with a tech company, then you are inherently not credible, that you are somehow in the pocket of fake tech, right? I think that that is a really short-sighted message. I know that this is something you and I are very united on, is that we need cross-sector collaboration. I mean, think about all the things that we are talking about here when it comes to young people and the issues that they are dealing with. It's ridiculous to think that we can solve this in silos. We need coalition building and collaboration among all of these sectors for this common goal, which I think we all have, which is helping young people thrive. I'll talk a little bit about my own experience. Ultimately, what your job is when you work in public policy or government relations is that you want to ensure that laws get passed that enable your business to grow and thrive. And there are a few ways that you do this. First, you have to present thoughtful positions on policy issues. So if you work in social media, that could be child safety, for example. If you work in AI, maybe it would be issues on labor or on climate, whatever the issues are that impact your company. And the policy position that Meta is fighting against is that they are harmful to kids and that people need to ban social media for kids.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the big ones. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Now, where a lot of companies get tripped up is that they think that public policy work is about selling themselves. I have had colleagues who have taken the approach of saying, okay, well, our policy position is that Meta is a great company. That's not a solid policy argument that any policymaker can stand on, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00And so what you have to do is you have to create a political environment that makes it viable for policymakers to support the policies that are good for your company.
SPEAKER_01Does
SPEAKER_00that make sense?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00I never start with anything that's meta first or Uber first. My experience is working with companies that are not very popular and that people don't really trust very much. So it was more about trying to align with others and have them amplify the position that you are trying to make. So from Meta's perspective on social media and kids safety, the policy position that I was trying to push through was that, well, it doesn't help to focus on specific platforms or specific technologies because technology is always evolving and you're just going to be playing whack-a-mole with new technologies with your policy. And you're always going to be playing catch up. The more strategic public policy to take would be to support media and digital literacy education for young people to help set them up for success as technology continues to evolve. Amplifying that message that involved building relationships with organizations like Namely and other partners that we have to essentially build programs and research and proof points around the value of education. So even though Namely, for example, may not trust Meta as a company and may not even like it, right? But we can still come together on a shared goal that media literacy education is absolutely crucial. And I have no expectation that organizations that I work with like my company, or even that they never criticize the company. In fact, I think that organizations are more credible and actually serve the interests of my company more if they are critical of us, because then it shows that they are not in the company's pocket.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, this is how we met, this is our origin story, this is, you know, where we fell in love, is doing these partnerships together. And I understand from the media literacy perspective why people think that we should never take a dollar from tech companies. I get that.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I understand it too. And full disclosure, I no longer work at Meta and I'm a current namely board member. So I've kind of switched sides and I absolutely understand that perspective. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I also knew that the difference I could make in really getting you at Meta to understand what effective media literacy practice and policy would look like was really important to media literacy.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Part of what I did when I was there is get Meta and YouTube and TikTok and Roblox and these major companies to recognize that they have to double down around media literacy. And if they paid us to do some resources for them that kept our work going, that seemed totally reasonable to me and necessary because that's the other thing is no one else is funding this space in a way that we needed funding. So we do need to look at it from all of these points of view. We're not going to get government funding. So that's out. It's a really limited foundation space. Back to height is that, you know, we're accusing these researchers of getting money from companies. That's just a complete lie. But if they were, the fact that it's attacking their credibility, I think is just an interesting thing to reckon with because maybe not.
SPEAKER_00Again, it's in the company's interest for the researchers to maintain editorial control of their research. It doesn't help a company to spout some study that they paid for and basically published themselves. Some companies may try to do that, but the research will not be credible and it's not going to actually serve their purpose.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up because I was thinking about probably some of this comes from past experiences with like smoking, when we have companies paying for research that proves something.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01I would imagine that some of this has to do with past stories about research that isn't credible that companies funded.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01But maybe this is a different scenario.
SPEAKER_00It also depends on who you're working with at the company. Like I described my own philosophy. So it is important if you're a nonprofit working with a tech company. A lot of it can come down to the individual person that you're working with and how they approach this kind of work and what kind of influence or independence they have within their company to foster the right kind of partnership with you. But that is something that you can assess with the person that you are speaking with. I think that there probably are people in companies who are more transactional, but definitely not all. And it's not inherently the case. I actually led policy research at Meta for a time, and I was on a policy research team at Uber. So I've worked regularly with academic researchers in a company perspective, and I've actually worked with real economists and political scientists on staff, even, whose job is to work with academics on research for the purpose of publishing papers and advancing knowledge in the field. These can be really important partnerships for research because tech companies are really great spaces for natural experiments. The data that you can get from these companies is really valuable for the purpose of psychological, economic, political science research, for example. This is a relatively common practice, but again, in all cases, it is extremely important for the external academic institutions to maintain editorial control. Of course, we collaborate on things like the research design. So when you're doing a survey, for example, it's very important that the wording of the questions are done very carefully. So it's clear, so it's not leading, and also so it's accurate for how the technology works that we're looking at, that we're trying to study. And a social psychologist may not know all the details of how information campaigns work on these platforms, right? And so it's important to have those kinds of insights to make sure that the surveys are designed accurately. That's just one example of the way that I've worked with academics before.
SPEAKER_01What I would like people to be thinking about, and I know what I was talking to my students about, because actually we talked about this particular topic in class this week. So it's very much top of mind. These are complex issues. The moment you see a simple answer is the moment you have to pause and think that maybe I'm not hearing everything. Right. You know, the moment we think we can solve a huge problem like teen mental health in a few easy steps is the moment that we should pause. As I think more and more about this, it feels in some ways that it's an incredibly good example of confirmation bias. That everyone who reads that book wants to believe that this is what's happening and wants to believe that this is the solution because we care about kids and we care about what happens to them. We care about them living in a world that feels safe. We want them to thrive, we want them to feel mentally healthy. And when you look at it, you can't ignore the fact that that so many researchers do not connect with the results of that book, do not connect with the story of that book, and that says something. And to me, this whisper campaign getting back into the news, making researchers defend themselves, we're missing the point here. We have to get back to what the problem is, which is we have a teen mental health crisis, and we have to solve that problem.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And no one book is going to do that.
SPEAKER_00So for people who might want to learn a little bit more, would you have any recommendations for them?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I'm actually gonna recommend something that you recommended to me this week when we were prepping.
SPEAKER_00Ooh lala.
SPEAKER_01I had never listened or watched the debate that Candace Odgers and Jonathan Haidt had at the University of Virginia called Making Sense of the Research on Social Media and Youth Mental Health. This is an hour and a half conversation between them and a moderator with questions from youth online and in person. And they go back and forth. And it's a really fascinating thing to watch them both defend their positions, to see where they agree, to see where they disagree. And if you are interested in this topic, you're interested in diving deeper, this is a great place to spend some time.
SPEAKER_00It's really fun to see their dynamic with each other.
SPEAKER_01How about you?
SPEAKER_00My recommendation is an essay called We Are Not the Anxious Generation by a student at Columbia University named Maximilian Milovidov. Maximilian is an absolutely brilliant youth advocate on tech issues. He's on TikTok's Youth Council, and he was also interviewed along with Jonathan Haidt on NPR's TED Radio Hour. So we'll link to that in the show notes as well. And Maximilian is going to be on a future episode of DigiC with another incredible youth advocate, Katie Ma, when we go to South by Southwest EDU next March. So thank you to everyone who voted and has supported and been listening along the way. We are so excited to be going to Austin and to be bringing these incredible young students to the stage. Youth Voice is so often absent from the conversation about youth and tech. And Maximilian's essay is such a powerful example of the kinds of insights and perspectives that must be included in these public policy conversations impacting young people.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so I think it would be appropriate to let Candace have the final word here. What do you think?
SPEAKER_00Let's do it. Thank you, Michelle, and thank you, Candace.
SPEAKER_02If our goal is to support young people, and I assume that we all share that, then we will fail if all we do is focus on tech and taking things away. If all we see when we look at our kids is their phone, we're gonna fail seeing what they really need from us.
SPEAKER_00Michelle Chula Lipkin has been a media literacy educator and advocate for the last 25 years. She teaches at the City University of New York and writes, presents, and consults on topics related to media and tech. You can find her at Michelle Chulalipkin.com.
SPEAKER_01Gina Wu spent 15 years in tech, building Uber as the first person on the ground in European and U.S. markets, and founding Meta's Global Information Ecosystem Program. Today she is the author of Feed for Thought, a newsletter that explores how digital platforms are reshaping standards for authority seats. GC with Gina and Michelle
SPEAKER_00is produced by Stevie Starr.
SPEAKER_01Our theme song is by Lon Jude.