Did You See? with Jena and Michelle

Did you see that Jonathan Haidt said Meta was planning a whisper campaign against him?

• Season 1 • Episode 11

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 46:23

Did Meta plan a secret campaign to discredit The Anxious Generation author, Jonathan Haidt? Why are his critics now having to defend their credibility?

UC Irvine professor Candice Odgers is one of many researchers challenging Haidt’s claims. Her work points to other factors affecting teen mental health and argues that social media bans punish rather than help young people.

Jena and Michelle also discuss whether organizations can work with tech companies without losing their independence. Jena shares the corporate perspective, while Michelle offers the nonprofit side.

Plus: The midterms deliver historic firsts and voters push back against Big Tech.

READ JENA'S ESSAY

Even a blue wave can’t save bad tech policy, 2026.

OUR RECS

Conversation with Candice Odgers & Jon Haidt: “Making sense of the research on social media and youth mental health,” University of Virginia, Thriving Youth in a Digital Environment (TYDE), 2024.

We’re not the anxious generation by Maximilian Milovidov, 2025.

AUDIO CLIP

What we’re getting wrong about teens and tech, Candice Odgers, TED, 2026.

2026 MIDTERMS

The 2026 midterm elections showed DEI is alive and well, Brookings, 2026.

The backlash against AI, in four charts, Fast Company, 2026.

Erratic, Distracted, Extravagant: How Elon Musk’s huge midterm bet flopped, The New York Times, 2026.

Voters rejected data centers. Many will be built anyway., The New York Times, 2026.

The youth shifts that defined the 2026 midterm elections, CIRCLE, 2026.

JONATHAN HAIDT 

Jonathan Haidt (Instagram), 2026.

Meta considered a “whisper strategy” to turn academics against Jonathan Haidt, The Verge, 2026.

Sanders’ letter to governors, Arkansas legislature concerning the mental health crisis kids are facing driven by social media, Governor SHS, 2024.

TIME100 Health: Jonathan Haidt, TIME, 2024.

RESEARCH ON YOUTH MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIAL MEDIA

Assessment of the impact of social media on the health and wellbeing of adolescents and children, National Academies, 2024.

Do smartphones really cause mental illness among adolescents? Ten problems with Jonathan Haidt’s book, Parenting for a Digital Future, London School of Economics, 2024.

The great rewiring: Is social media really behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?  by Candice Odgers, Nature, 2024.

No. I was not paid to critique The Anxious Generation. I came to the conclusion that the science was flawed all on my own., Growing Up Digital (Candice Odgers), 2026.

No one paid me to disagree with Jonathan Haidt. It was teenagers who taught me that he was wrong., Made Not Found (by Danah Boyd), 2026.

We interrupt our usual programming to inform you that I was never hired by Facebook to do a hit job on Jonathan Haidt., Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science (Andrew Gelman), 2026.

People on this episode